What’s that defect…. Rocks and rock faces

Rock faces alongside a road can pose significant risks to road users. These risks can arise from several factors such as rockfall, loose debris, and potential instability. The risks can be heightened in areas with significant weather events, such as heavy rain or snowfall, which can destabilise rock formations. The consequences of rockfall incidents can be severe, including damage to vehicles, injuries or fatalities to road users, and road closures, which can cause significant disruption to traffic flow. As such, it is important for road authorities to implement measures to manage and mitigate the risks posed by rock faces alongside roads.

Here are some likely defects that can be found from rock faces:

  1. Rock falls or debris on the road surface.
  2. Cracks or fissures on the rock face.
  3. Loose or unstable rock formations.
  4. Vegetation or trees growing on the rock face.
  5. Water seepage or drainage issues causing erosion or landslides.
  6. Lack of or damage to protective measures such as rockfall barriers or mesh netting.
  7. Poor visibility or lighting around the rock face area.
  8. Unauthorised access or activity on the rock face.
  9. Signs of wildlife activity, such as burrows or nesting sites, that may pose a hazard to road users.
  10. Obstructions caused by rock or debris buildup in drainage channels or culverts.

Remedial measures to rock faces alongside roads are necessary to reduce the risk of hazards to road users. The risks posed by rock faces can range from loose rock debris to rockfall, which can cause damage to vehicles and injury to drivers and passengers. Additionally, rocks or boulders that have become detached from the rock face can obstruct the roadway, leading to potential accidents or damage to vehicles. Therefore, it is important to implement remedial measures to minimize these risks and ensure the safety of road users. These measures may include slope stabilisation, rockfall protection systems, and regular inspections to identify potential hazards and implement necessary repairs.

Here are some of the remedial measures that can be used to address defects from rock faces:

  1. Scaling: Loose and unstable rock material is removed from the rock face to prevent potential falling hazards.
  2. Rock bolting: This technique involves drilling into the rock face and installing a steel bolt to hold the rock face in place and prevent rock falls.
  3. Shotcrete: This is a process where a layer of sprayed-on concrete is applied to the rock face to stabilise the surface and protect against weathering and erosion.
  4. Mesh and netting: Wire mesh or netting can be installed over the rock face to contain loose rocks and debris.
  5. Catch fences: These are barriers installed at the base of a rock face to catch any falling rocks or debris.
  6. Rockfall barriers: These are steel barriers that are placed on the slope above the road to catch any falling rocks or debris and prevent them from reaching the road.
  7. Slope stabilization: This involves reshaping or modifying the slope to reduce the risk of rock falls or other hazards.

The remedial measures used will depend on the type and severity of the defect, as well as the location and accessibility of the rock face. Inspections of rock faces are typically carried out by qualified engineers who are trained to identify potential hazards and recommend appropriate remedial measures. Inspections may be conducted visually, or may involve the use of specialised equipment such as drones or laser scanning technology to assess the condition of the rock face.

Inspections are carried out by trained personnel who follow guidelines set out by the UK government to identify and document any defects found. These guidelines include specific requirements for the types of defects that may be encountered. The inspections are carried out on a regular basis, and any defects that are identified are addressed through appropriate maintenance and repair measures. The ultimate goal is to ensure the safety of all road users and prevent accidents caused by rock hazards.

What’s that defect…. Ironwork

Ironwork, including manhole covers, gully grates, and utility covers, are critical components of road infrastructure. They provide access to drainage and utility systems and are designed to be strong enough to support vehicular traffic. However, over time, ironwork can deteriorate due to various factors, such as weathering, corrosion, and general wear and tear. Defects in ironwork can pose significant hazards to road users, such as vehicle damage, accidents, and noise pollution. Therefore, it is essential to identify and address these defects as part of a regular maintenance program.

Here are some types of ironwork defects that can be found on UK roads:

  1. Broken or missing covers – this can cause a hazard to vehicles and pedestrians as well as damage to the ironwork below.
  2. Damaged or displaced frames – this can cause noise, vibration, and potential hazards to vehicles and pedestrians.
  3. Inadequate bearings – this can cause problems with movement or rocking, leading to noise and damage.
  4. Corrosion or rusting – this can lead to weakened ironwork and potential failure, as well as aesthetic issues.
  5. Obstructed or blocked gratings – this can lead to ponding, flooding, and damage to the surrounding area.
  6. Incorrect height adjustment – this can cause issues with drainage and may lead to damage to the surrounding road surface.
  7. Insufficient edge clearance – this can cause issues with vehicle and pedestrian access as well as damage to the surrounding ironwork and road surface.
  8. Inadequate sealing or filling – this can cause problems with drainage, and may lead to further issues with corrosion or rusting.

These defects can lead to hazards, damage to infrastructure, and reduced service life of ironwork components. It is important to regularly inspect and maintain ironwork to ensure safe and efficient use of UK roads.

What’s that defect…. Road drainage systems

The drainage system of a highway should be designed, constructed, and maintained to efficiently and effectively manage water and reduce the risk of flooding. The drainage system should be inspected and maintained regularly to prevent defects and ensure functionality. The drainage system plays a crucial role in ensuring the safe use of the highways network. A failure of the drainage system to provide adequate drainage can lead to flooding on the carriageway or adjacent land, which is a significant safety issue for road users.

Drainage Components

There are numerous components of a drainage system, each with specific functions and potential defects. These include piped drainage systems, gullies, catchpits, grit traps, interceptors, soakaways, manholes, piped grips, grips, ditches, filter drains, narrow filter drains, culverts, vegetative drainage systems for highway runoff, ancillary items, linear drainage systems, road-edge surface water channels, grassed surface water channels, and flooding. Defects in these components can include blockages, silt build-up, erosion, damage, incorrect gradient, insufficient capacity, and more. Proper inspection, maintenance, and operation of these drainage components are necessary to prevent flooding, structural damage, and safety hazards on highways.

  1. Drainage General: This covers the general management of the highway drainage system, including the collection, conveyance, storage, treatment, and disposal of highway runoff. It includes the coordination and integration of various drainage assets and features such as gullies, catchpits, ditches, culverts, and filter drains. The drainage system of a highway should be designed, constructed, and maintained to efficiently and effectively manage water and reduce the risk of flooding. The drainage system should be inspected and maintained regularly to prevent defects and ensure functionality. Symptoms of a poorly functioning drainage system include ponding, flooding, erosion, and pavement cracking. Drainage defects may include blockages, damage to pipes or channels, improper gradient or alignment, and erosion of banks or bed.
  2. Piped drainage systems: This includes underground drainage systems that use pipes to convey surface water runoff to a designated outfall. Piped drainage systems are designed to collect and convey surface water runoff away from the highway. Symptoms of a poorly functioning piped drainage system include blockages, ponding, and flooding. Defects may include damage to pipes or channels, joint failure, and silt or debris buildup. The pipes may be made of various materials such as concrete, plastic, or metal, and may range in size from small diameter pipes to large culverts.
  3. Gullies, catchpits, grit traps, interceptors, soakaways, & manholes: These are various types of drainage features that are used to capture and manage surface water runoff. Gullies and catchpits are used to collect runoff from the road surface, while grit traps and interceptors are used to separate and remove sediment and pollutants. Soakaways are used to dispose of excess runoff, and manholes provide access to the underground drainage system for maintenance purposes. Gullies, catchpits, grit traps, interceptors, soakaways, and manholes are critical components of a drainage system. Symptoms of a poorly functioning gully or catchpit include ponding, flooding, and blockages. Defects may include damage to the cover or frame, silt or debris buildup, and joint failure.
  4. Piped grips: These are small-scale drainage channels or ditches that are used to collect and convey surface water runoff. They are typically lined with concrete or other materials and may be covered with grates or other types of covers. Piped grips are designed to convey water away from the highway. Symptoms of a poorly functioning piped grip include ponding and flooding. Defects may include damage to pipes, joint failure, and silt or debris buildup.
  5. Grips: These are open drainage channels or ditches that are used to collect and convey surface water runoff. Grips are unlined channels designed to convey water away from the highway. They are typically unlined with vegetation but may be lined with other materials. Symptoms of a poorly functioning grip include erosion, sediment buildup, and vegetation growth. Defects may include erosion of banks, sediment buildup, and vegetation growth.
  6. Ditches: These are open drainage channels or ditches that are used to collect and convey surface water runoff. Ditches are lined or unlined channels designed to convey water away from the highway. They are typically lined with vegetation and may be designed to provide additional benefits such as flood storage, erosion control, or water quality improvement. Symptoms of a poorly functioning ditch include erosion, sediment buildup, and vegetation growth. Defects may include erosion of banks, sediment buildup, and vegetation growth.
  7. Filter drains & fin/narrow filter drains: These are subsurface drainage systems that are designed to collect and convey surface water runoff to a designated outfall. Filter drains and fin/narrow filter drains are designed to collect and filter surface water runoff. They are typically made of granular material and may be used in conjunction with a geotextile fabric or other materials to filter out sediment and other pollutants. Symptoms of a poorly functioning filter drain include blockages, ponding, and flooding.
  8. Culverts: Culverts are structures designed to convey surface water runoff under roads, railways, or other features. They may be made of various materials such as concrete, plastic, or metal and may be designed to accommodate different flow rates and capacities. Symptoms of a poorly functioning culvert include ponding, flooding, and erosion. Defects may include damage to the culvert or inlet, blockages, and joint failure.
  9. Vegetative drainage systems for highway runoff: These are natural or constructed systems that are designed to collect, treat, and dispose of surface water runoff. They typically consist of vegetation and soil media that help to capture and filter out pollutants and sediments. Symptoms of a poorly functioning vegetative drainage system include erosion, sediment buildup, and vegetation growth. Defects may include erosion of banks, sediment buildup, and vegetation growth.
  10. Ancillary items: These are various components of the drainage system such as access covers, outfalls, weirs, and other features that are used to manage the flow of surface water runoff. Defects may include damage to the item or foundation, silt or debris buildup, and ironwork failure.
  11. Linear drainage systems: These are drainage systems that are designed to collect and convey surface water runoff along the length of a road or other feature. They typically consist of a channel or slot drain that is installed along the edge of the road surface. Symptoms of a poorly functioning linear drainage system include blockages, ponding, and flooding. Defects may include damage to the channel or inlet, silt or debris buildup, and vegetation growth.
  12. Road-edge surface water channels: These are small-scale drainage channels that are installed along the edge of the road surface to collect and convey surface water runoff. They may be made of various materials such as concrete, plastic, or metal and may be covered with grates or other types of covers. Symptoms of a poorly functioning road-edge surface water channel include ponding, flooding, and erosion. Defects include blockages caused by debris or vegetation, damage to the channel lining, and erosion or settling of the channel bed.
  13. Grassed surface water channels: These are open drainage channels or ditches that are lined with vegetation and are used to collect and convey surface water runoff. They may be designed to provide water quality treatment by allowing vegetation to absorb pollutants and sediment, as well as providing habitat for wildlife. Grassed surface water channels should be inspected regularly for any blockages, erosion or damage to the vegetation lining, and any necessary maintenance work should be carried out promptly to ensure effective operation. In addition, excess vegetation growth should be controlled to prevent blockages and ensure the channel remains clear and free-flowing.

One of the most critical aspects of maintenance are Category 1 defects of the drainage system. Category 1 defects in the drainage system are those that pose an imminent safety risk to road users and require immediate attention and repair. These defects are considered to be the highest priority and should be addressed as soon as possible to ensure the safety of the road network.

Examples of Category 1 defects in the drainage system include:

  1. Blocked gully causing standing water on live carriageway: A blocked gully can result in standing water on the live carriageway, creating a potential hazard for road users, particularly during adverse weather conditions such as heavy rain or snow.
  2. Blocked ditch causing flooding on live carriageway or adjacent land: A blocked ditch can result in flooding on the live carriageway or adjacent land, creating a potential hazard for road users.
  3. Pollution of the drainage system: The presence of hazardous or toxic materials within the drainage system can pose a significant risk to the environment and road users.
  4. Flooding of live carriageway: Flooding of the live carriageway can pose a significant hazard to road users and can be caused by a variety of factors, including blocked gullies or ditches, subsidence, or heavy rainfall.

Symptoms of a poorly functioning drainage system include ponding, flooding, erosion, and pavement cracking. Drainage defects may include blockages, damage to pipes or channels, improper gradient or alignment, and erosion of banks or bed, carriageway flooding, blocked ditches, flooded ditch systems, and pollution of the drainage system.

A blocked gully can cause standing water on the live carriageway, which creates a hazard for drivers and can result in reduced visibility and increased braking distances. A blocked ditch can cause flooding on the live carriageway or adjacent land, which can result in the road being temporarily closed.

Category 2 defects in the drainage system refer to those that are less severe than Category 1 defects and do not pose an imminent safety risk to road users. However, they still require attention and repair within a defined timescale.

Examples of Category 2 defects in the drainage system include:

  1. A partially blocked gully, which does not cause standing water on the live carriageway but may reduce the efficiency of the drainage system.
  2. A minor leak in a pipe or ditch, which does not result in significant flooding but may need repair to prevent further deterioration of the asset.
  3. A small depression in the carriageway caused by subsidence, which does not pose an imminent safety risk but may cause water to pond on the surface and affect the efficiency of the drainage system.
  4. A gully or ditch that is partially clogged with debris, which does not cause significant flooding but may need cleaning to maintain the efficiency of the drainage system.

It is important to note that Category 2 defects should still be monitored and repaired in a timely manner to prevent them from becoming Category 1 defects, which can pose an imminent safety risk to road users. Highways agencies are responsible for ensuring that Category 2 defects are repaired within a defined timescale and that the drainage system is functioning effectively.

Pollution Risks to the Drainage System

The pollution of the drainage system can also have serious consequences for the safe use of the highways network. Polluted water can contain toxic chemicals or oil spills, which can be harmful to the environment and can cause a slippery surface on the carriageway, creating a hazard for drivers. Pollution of the drainage system is a serious issue that can have far-reaching consequences for the environment and road users. The pollution of the drainage system can occur from a variety of sources, including trade or industrial waste, hazardous materials, and the dumping of controlled materials. In the event of an incident associated with trade or industrial waste, hazardous materials, or any visible warning signs or chemical symbols displayed on the trade or industrial vehicles involved, it is essential that immediate action is taken to contain and clean up the spill.

Additional consideration should be given to oil or diesel spillages, which can pose a significant risk to the environment and road users. In such cases, it is important to determine whether the pollution observed causes a localised or more extensive network issue. Controlled materials, such as oil and paint drums, organic waste, sharps materials, and refrigerators/freezers, can also contribute to the pollution of the drainage system.

It is crucial to be vigilant in monitoring and preventing the pollution of the drainage system. Regular inspections and prompt action in the event of a spill can help minimize the impact of the pollution on the environment and road users. By taking proactive measures, highways agencies can help ensure the continued safe and efficient functioning of the drainage system.

The maintenance and successful resolution of defects of the drainage system are critical to the safe use of the highways network during winter weather conditions. Service codes outline the maintenance requirements to prevent the occurrence of these defects and ensure that the highways network is safe to use during winter weather conditions. It is important for highways agencies to regularly inspect and maintain the drainage system to prevent the occurrence of these category 1 defects, which can result in the failure of the asset to provide adequate drainage and cause imminent flooding of the carriageway or adjacent land.

Inspection of the Drainage System

Inspecting a drainage system is an important part of ensuring that it is in good working order and that maintenance is being properly carried out. Here are some steps that could be taken to inspect a drainage system:

  1. Check drainage records: Start by checking the records for the drainage system. These records should include the location of the drainage system, its design and construction, and any maintenance or repairs that have been carried out.
  2. Visual inspection: Carry out a visual inspection of the drainage system. Look for any signs of damage, such as cracks or breaks in the pipes, or evidence of blockages, such as standing water or debris in the drainage channels.
  3. Check inlets and outlets: Check that the inlets and outlets of the drainage system are clear and not blocked. Ensure that the inlets are properly connected to the road surface and that there is no evidence of erosion around the outlets.
  4. Test the flow rate: Carry out a flow rate test to check that the drainage system is capable of coping with the amount of water it is designed to handle. This can be done by pouring a known amount of water into the inlet and measuring the time it takes for the water to flow through the system.
  5. Check the surrounding area: Inspect the surrounding area to ensure that there are no signs of flooding or other water damage. Check that any adjacent land is not being affected by the drainage system.
  6. Document your findings: Document your findings from the inspection and use this information to inform any necessary maintenance or repair work.

Regular inspections of the drainage system can help to ensure that it is in good working order and that any necessary maintenance is carried out in a timely manner. By taking a proactive approach to maintenance, potential issues can be identified and addressed before they become more serious problems.

What’s that defect?

There is a central body responsible for the operation, maintenance and improvement of roads. In England it is Highways England who has an obligation to provide safe roads and reliable journeys for the road user, Scottish roads are managed by Transport Scotland, Welsh roads by the Welsh Assembly, local roads by the relevant local authority and roads in London by TfL (Transport for London).

In the English instance Highways England are responsible for the motorways and major trunk roads which totals around 4,300 miles (about 2% of all roads in England by length). Whilst only a small number the roads carry a third of all traffic by milage and two thrids of all heavy good traffic.

Under the Highways (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1961, highway authorities have an obligation to maintain public highways to reasonable standards and this is done with the help of a document which is used by the maintainers called the Routine and Winter Service Code (RWSC). This RWSC identifies the Category of the defect, the duration of any hazard mitigation and the permanent repair period duration for the contractual timeframe.

The definition of a Cat 1 defect as defined in the RWSC is;

  • Defects are those that require prompt attention because there is an immediate or imminent safety risk
  • Significant disruption to the normal flow of traffic through the Network
  • Structural deterioration
  • Damage to the environment
  • Offence to road users from graffiti that is obscene, blasphemous or otherwise offensive

The definition of a Cat 2 defects as defined in the RWSC are sub-divided into two categories;

  • Category 2.1 – Not superficial
  • Category 2.2 – Superficial (i.e. does not change the characteristic or function of the asset/item)

To keep it interesting we can look at Cat 1 defects which need us to make safe, permanent repairs within a contractual time frame and defects that, due to their nature and/or location, require intervention from an Incident Support Unit (ISU) within the contractual response times. This will all vary depending upon time of day and location and can either be dealt with immediately by a Network Maintenance Crew, an ISU or where it requires a more expansive response; such as lane closures or traffic management to protect the road user whilst hazard mitigation works take place.

Initially Cat 1 defects can be dealt with in 2 different ways: reactive or proactive, and with everything else the second respective is always better.

Reactive maintenance – Cat 1 defects identified by an external third party source…Police, Highways England Traffic Officers, Local Authorities or occasionally even direct via the public.

Proactive maintenance – Cat 1 defects identified by the Incident Support Units, depot based operatives, office based staff or Inspection teams driving the Network.

In addition to those defects listed in the bulleted points above we can look at defects as examples going forward and what constitutes a Category 1 defect. As always the caveat within the RWSC is that any list should not be regarded as exhaustive, because ultimately a defect can appear at anytime with anything on any Network, this ultimately just makes life that little bit more interesting and challenging.

To get a full idea of what to look for under Cat 1 defects (and in no particular order) I am going to ask around for examples from my contacts and look at the following over the coming months;

  1. Potholes and other local defects in the carriageway/footway/cycle track, including defective ironwork
  2. Excessive standing water and water discharging on to and/or flowing across the road
  3. Damaged road restraint systems and other barriers
  4. Debris and spillage in traffic lanes or on hardshoulders
  5. Kerbing, edging and channel defects
  6. Damaged lighting columns and other street furniture
  7. Damaged, defective, displaced or missing traffic signs or signals
  8. Dirty or otherwise obscure traffic signs and signals
  9. Trees, shrubs and hedges which by virtue of their position or condition constitute hazard to road users and the travelling general public
  10. Displaced roadstuds (particularly the cast “Catseye” type) lying in the carriageway, hardshoulder or laybys
  11. Defective, missing or loose roadstuds
  12. Faults in road structures e.g. impact damage to superstructures, supports or parapets, flood damage, insecure expansion joints
  13. Damage and defects in structures carrying water beneath the roads
  14. Difference in level (exceeding 20mm) between abutting concrete slabs at transverse or longitudinal joints in the carriageway/footway/cycle track
  15. Rocking gratings or covers in urban areas causing intrusive noise
  16. Damaged boundary fences where animals or children could gain access
  17. Defective road and sign lighting
  18. Overhead wires in a dangerous condition
  19. Blocked gully and piped grip gratings and obstructed channels, grips and slot drains
  20. Earthslips where debris has encroached or is likely to encroach on to the road
  21. Rocks or rock faces constituting a hazard to road users.